Was Mr. Berhman right in doing what he did? Why or why not?
38 Comments
Jared Victor
9/30/2014 07:12:04 am
I believe Mr. Berhman did the right thing because without his masterpiece, Johnsy or Joanna would have given up on herself and possibly died.
Reply
Emily Hurtado
9/30/2014 07:19:12 am
I believe Mr. Berham did the right thing because he didn't think about himself. He was like Jesus who died for our sins.
Reply
Jared Victor
9/30/2014 11:03:41 am
I agree as well Emily.
Reply
Karissa Garcia
9/30/2014 07:32:03 am
I think Mr. Berham did the right thing because he risked his life to save Johnsy life and to not let Johnsy give up.
Reply
Aidan Reynolds
9/30/2014 08:03:35 am
I think Berham did the right thing because he sacrificed his life for Johnsy and finally got to make his masterpiece.
Reply
Gabriela Vasquez
9/30/2014 08:06:55 am
I think what Bremen did was right because he sacrificed his life to save Johnsys life.
Reply
Isabella Dávalos
9/30/2014 08:26:00 am
I think Berhman did the right thing because he risked his own life to show Johnsy through his art that there is still a chance that she will live.
Reply
Kiana LaBella
9/30/2014 08:28:43 am
I do believe that Behrman did the right thing beacause if he hadn't painted the leaf, Johnsy/Joanna would have died. The book is pretty much saying that Behrman risked his life for the health of Johnsy/Joanna
Reply
daniel myers
9/30/2014 08:52:39 am
I believe that Mr. Behrman did the right thing. I think that because he died painting something so Johnsy would live.
Reply
Skye
9/30/2014 10:04:54 am
I do think that Berhman did the right thing because he wanted her to have hope in living.
Reply
Fatima Ruiz
9/30/2014 10:09:32 am
I believe that Berhman did the right thing because he didn't do it for himself. He thought about Jonnsy.
Reply
Adrian
9/30/2014 10:10:51 am
I think Berhman did the right thing because he wanted to make her have hope to live
Reply
Sophie Mena
9/30/2014 10:37:26 am
I think that Berhman did the right thiing because he risked he life, basically sacrifice himself for Johnsy. And he finally painted his masterpiece, which is better than any other painting because he saved someone's life.
Reply
Julia Godinez
9/30/2014 10:41:25 am
I think it was right was right what Berhman did because he saved Johnsy's life by painting the last leaf out in the cloud and got pneumonia and died.
Reply
Kelvin Ramos
9/30/2014 10:51:45 am
I think Berhman did this because he wanted Johnsy to have hope in her self so she could live and he made his masterpiece
Reply
Derryl Quiamco
9/30/2014 11:15:04 am
I think that Berhman did the right thing because if he didn't pant the leaf ( His masterpiece) Johnsy could have died from pneumonia
Reply
derryl quiamco
9/30/2014 01:57:36 pm
ignor this
Reply
Ryan Sulka
9/30/2014 11:22:16 am
I think Berhman did do the right thing because he wanted to save johnsy from dying. So he went out into the cold and painted a leaf on the vine so johnsy wouldn't die.
Reply
Isaac Marcelo Lopez
9/30/2014 11:36:11 am
I believe that Mr. Behrman did the right thing, because it is a very selfless thing to give up your life for someone else. It seems that Behrman cares for Johnsy and so he painted the last leaf so she won't suffer death, but for him to. He sacrificed himself to save Johnsy's life. That's why I believe Mr. Behrman did the right thing.
Reply
Alexander Ramirez
9/30/2014 11:51:48 am
I think that Berman did the right thing because instead of making fun of the softness Sue showed. He made Johnsy have hope and he finaly had made his masterpiece.
Reply
Sophie Navarro
9/30/2014 12:39:31 pm
I think Berhman did the right thing because he saved Johnsy's life by helping her realize that others need her.(Sue) And also Berhman got to paint his master piece.
Reply
Chelsea Cruz
9/30/2014 12:42:28 pm
i think Behrman did the right thing beacuse he told Johnsy why she would believe her foolish nosence beacuse Johnsy would say that the last leaf will fall when she dies but instead it didnt fall. It fell when had died and he had done a beautiful master piece so i beleive Behrman had done the right thing
Reply
9/30/2014 12:53:06 pm
I believe that Mr.Berhman was doing right when he paint the leaf because in doing so he made Johnsy believe that the last leaf did not fall and as a result tricking her to live longer. (Ironically longer than even him)
Reply
Diego
9/30/2014 12:58:26 pm
I think Bergman was doing the right thing helping her believe she will live because she was losing her hope
Reply
Gavin Aco
9/30/2014 01:07:03 pm
*Berhman
Reply
Erika Tagle
9/30/2014 01:04:08 pm
I believe that Behrman did the right thing because he died painting the picture of the last leaf for Johnsy. In a way he did the same thing that Jesus did and died for Johnsy.
Reply
Gavin Aco
9/30/2014 01:05:27 pm
Berhman did a selfless act to paint a leaf for Johnsy so she wouldn't lose hope and possibly die. Berhman did a caring and the right thing and shows that even if he scuffs at softness, he was soft as well.
Reply
Derryl Quiamco
9/30/2014 01:56:10 pm
Yes, because Mr. Berman is old and has lived his life and he wants Jonnsy to live longer so she can her life.
Reply
Bennett Annan
9/30/2014 02:25:45 pm
I believe that Berhman was doing the right not the wrong, because his masterpiece was a leaf on a window so Johnny would not die by giving up
Reply
Tyler Marty
9/30/2014 02:38:42 pm
I think Mr. Berhman did the right thing because if it wasn't for him finally creating his masterpiece by painting a leaf on the brick wall, Johnsy would of only had he 1 in 10 chance of living because of her loss of hope the doctor mentioned and die. Because the masterpiece was created, she still felt she had hope and recived the illusion she could survive longer, giving her the 5 in 10 chance the doctor mentioned, giving her the boost to stay alive and not die. Mr. Berhman was selfless and sacrificed his own life instead of her's. It was the right thing to do.
Reply
Ela Rybak
9/30/2014 11:32:24 pm
I think that without Berhman's masterpiece Johnsy could have possibly given up and died. Bergman was not be selfish either he did a good deed even if that means that something bad happens after the good deed. (< him dying)
Reply
Chase Call
10/1/2014 06:17:15 am
I believe mr berm an did the right thing because he's sacrificed his life for jonnsy
Reply
Davin Villareal
10/1/2014 11:09:16 am
I think that Mr. Behrman did a very good thing because he's always dreamed of making a masterpiece and he finally got to make one, and he also saved Johnsy's life by sacrificing himself so that Johnsy can live.
Reply
Angelique Altamira
10/1/2014 12:22:46 pm
I think that Mr. Berhman did the right thing because he has a strong feeling for Johsny and he was like I can't let her die I need to help her so he draw a leaf and helps Johsny live and he has done his master art work which is great and helps her to live.
Reply
Jeanette Andia
10/1/2014 12:27:02 pm
I think that Mr. Berhman did the right thing because of he haven't paint the last leave Johnsy would have died
Reply
Adrian
10/1/2014 01:04:30 pm
I don't think that Johnsy would of died. I think that if he did not help her, than she would of died.
Reply
Adi Ure
10/2/2014 10:48:30 am
I think he did the right thing because he kept Joanna alive.
Reply
Melanie
10/2/2014 01:09:00 pm
I think that Behrman did the right thing because he did not want Johnsy to die just because when the las ivy leaf fell should would have to die. Behrman finally get to created his masterpiece and that helped Johnsy belive better that she can survive.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
April 2015
Categories |